Science and knowledge
New frog discovered in New York City
Why the 'Man in the Moon' faces Earth
Jilted fruit flies turn to alcohol
Fertilisers behind increase in N2O levels
Early Earth hazy one day, clear the next
Could air pollution be making us fat?
Frog skin protein may help fight superbugs
Electrotherapy dampens brain connections
Satellite images spot early settlements
Chemistry helps sperm find the right egg
Social butterflies find safety in numbers
Ibuprofen reduces altitude sickness: study
Mercury findings raise new questions
Megafauna collapse led to mega changes
New device invisible to magnetic fields
Travelling gnome answers weighty question
Study throws Moon theory up in the air
James Cameron reaches bottom of Pacific
Link builds between extremes and warming
Some chocolate-eaters have lower BMI
Dingoes, devils may be angels in disguise
Barefoot running less energy efficient
Dolphin males share human social network
Recycled spectacles twice that of new: study
Study throws Moon theory up in the air
New questions have been raised about the birth of the Moon after a new study found samples from Earth and the lunar surface to be virtually identical.

The study reported in the journal Nature Geoscience contradicts the theory that the Moon formed after the impact of a Mars-sized object named Theia with the early Earth about 4.5 billion years ago.

At the time both the Earth and Theia were still partially molten, the impact causing Theia's core to sink into the Earth's core, while lighter ejecta and debris was thrown into space eventually coalescing to form the Moon.

The new study by Junjun Zhang, of the University of Chicago, and colleagues compared isotopic ratios of titanium in lunar and terrestrial samples.

Zhang and colleagues found the ratio of titanium isotopes on both Earth and the Moon to be identical to within about four parts per million.
Numbers don't add up

Because the Mars-sized impactor is expected to have been isotopically different, the measurements suggest the Moon is either made entirely of material from Earth, or intense mixing occurred on both bodies after impact.

Zhang and colleagues say the similarity can't be explained by both bodies forming in the same part of the solar system because meteorite samples show extensive diversity in titanium isotopic ratios.

They conclude the isotopes are far more likely to have come from Earth rather than another planet.
Devil is in the details

Planetary scientist Dr Brad Carter from the University of Southern Queensland says while it's unlikely to have two planets with the same chemical composition, it's not impossible.

"Despite what the paper says, a planet forming very close to the early Earth could have a similar composition resulting in similar isotopic ratios," says Carter.

"It's also possible that Theia was essentially made of ice, something from the Kuiper belt in the outer solar system."

"This would have provided the energy of impact, but with the ice evaporating away leaving Earth material to eject into space and form the moon."

Another option suggested by Zhang and colleagues involved the proto-Earth spinning much faster than previously thought, allowing a greater degree of mixing.

"However we don't really think Earth had spun rapidly enough for that to happen," says Carter.

"And then you have the problem of slowing down the Earth's rotation afterwards."

"Zhang and colleagues suggest a gravitational resonance effect between the Earth, Moon and Sun may have provided the forces needed to slow down the Earth's spin rate," says Carter.

Despite the problems, Carter believes the paper makes a good point about the need for revision of the current theory.

"The simple idea of Theia slamming into Earth remains sound," says Carter.

"But we need to refine current theories that don't explain the incredible similarities of isotopic ratios between the Earth and the Moon."

Для печати
Astronomers uncover stardust origins
Guns make people seem bigger
Traditional Chinese medicines under scrutiny
Baboons leave scientists spell-bound
Mars Viking robots 'found life'
Nothing helps create pure randomness
Jet lagged bees may help patient recovery
Study calls for regulating salt in fast foods
NASA clears SpaceX for space supply run
Egg size was dinos ultimate undoing
Peripheral vision snaps brain 'video' power
Study raises hopes of cure for baldness
Cosmic rays leave scientists in the dark
Bone-protecting protein discovered
Thylacine DNA reveals lacks of diversity
Aspirin's fat burning mechanism found
Polar bears are no new kids on the block
Calls back evolutionary gender theory
Asteroid impact pushes life underground
Arctic Ocean could be source of methane
Statins don't reduce melanoma risk
Facebook beauty is more than screen deep
Your brain could become your password
One hit of ecstasy 'resets body clock'
Antacid armour key to tetrapod survival
Fathers just as likely to get baby blues
Maths explains left-handed boxer success
Scientist claims to have found G-spot
Sprawling cities pressure environment
Fossil raindrops reveal early atmosphere
Fossil find reveals steps back in time
Report suggests new formula for Earth
Handprints may give away your height, gender
Monster solar tornadoes discovered
Study reveals why some soccer players dive
Teen brains undergo neural pruning
Martian dark spots reveal heart of glass
Cave holds earliest sign of fire-use
Stress may alter body's immune response
Japanese bees cook enemy in 'bee ball'
Tired locusts hold breath to rest their brains
X-rays shed new light on lung function
Mutant bird flu 'much less lethal'
T-rex had a giant feathered ancestor
Carbon dioxide ended last Ice Age: study
Saving ships from Titanic's fate
Dental x-rays linked to brain tumours
Fire-free farming in pre-Columbian Amazon
Teamwork made humans brainier: study
Drug data should be made public: report
Omega-3 pills may not help heart disease
Pigeons' sixth sense eludes scientists
Visit Statistics